|
|
|
|
|
|
BMW Garage | BMW Meets | Register | Today's Posts | Search |
|
BMW 3-Series (E90 E92) Forum
>
Is it true you shouldn’t touch a high mileage transmission?
|
|
03-23-2024, 01:20 AM | #1 |
Registered
0
Rep 1
Posts |
Is it true you shouldn’t touch a high mileage transmission?
Almost 200k miles on an automatic e90 2006 330i. I don’t have a ton of knowledge on cars nor the right vocabulary to describe to exact issue, but the gears feel like they could shift smoother than have been lately. Auto shifter itself feels a little sticky when moving between Park-Drive. I don’t intend to fully service the transmission, but wanted to drain and replace the trans fluid. I’ve often heard that you should not touch old transmissions. Is this a myth? I could go without https://9apps.ooo/ doing this service, the driving isn’t horribly compromised, but it could be better.
Last edited by warev; 03-28-2024 at 09:56 AM.. |
03-23-2024, 01:28 AM | #2 |
DIYer
266
Rep 306
Posts |
If it's still running well at this point, changing the fluid and filter would be ideal and will likely not hurt anything. In most cases if you have torque shudder like I did, if it is fluid related, instant shudder fix will address the issue. If it is mechanically related then the shudder fix would likely not have affected the issue.
As yours isn't having much of any issue it should be a good preventative maintenance item to tackle. I already did my filter and fluid change once but still need to change the fluid a few more times to really get it cleaned out. In my case the shudder fixx stuff really helped with my problem but it shows up from time to time driving in the city. If you do decide to drop the pan and filter I would recommend using an inch pound wrench on the new bolts. |
Appreciate
2
StradaRedlands4946.00 jbash87249.50 |
03-23-2024, 10:40 PM | #3 |
Brigadier General
4946
Rep 3,006
Posts
Drives: 2006 BMW 330i MT
Join Date: Dec 2021
Location: SoCal
iTrader: (2)
Garage List 2006 BMW 330i [8.21]
2009 BMW 328i Touri ... [7.90] 2013 BMW X5 35i [7.63] 2011 BMW 528i [8.75] 2006 Mazda3 [5.50] |
Change the fluid/filter. Too bad it wasn't done on time, but most aren't.
|
Appreciate
2
jbellk75rt127.00 Bims328i266.00 |
03-23-2024, 10:43 PM | #4 |
Lieutenant Colonel
1082
Rep 1,676
Posts |
I have heard that myth, but I would rather have fresh fluid in the transmission and old. A drain and refill only changes out about half the capacity, therefore that may be a good compromise.
The filter is likely plugged to a good extent too, but I would not do both at the same time, in case you have concerns of introducing too much detergent from the fresh ATF. |
Appreciate
1
lowrydr3101684.50 |
03-24-2024, 01:48 AM | #5 | |
Brigadier General
964
Rep 3,854
Posts
Drives: 330i, 135i
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: San Diego CA
|
Quote:
Had same issues like 5 yrs ago, I changed my solenoids, mechatronic sleeve gaskets and fluid at around 175k miles? Something like that. Tranny still working great after 5 yrs. Prob need to replace fluid soon. |
|
Appreciate
1
StradaRedlands4946.00 |
03-24-2024, 10:23 AM | #6 |
First Lieutenant
150
Rep 324
Posts |
The only time it seems to be an issue is when you already have problems. Change the fluid and filter. I changed the fluid ran it a bit then changed the fluid and filter. That way you get a pretty good change of fluid. If it's a GM unit put a tube or 2 of shudder fix in . Cured my shudder issue at about 150k miles.
|
Appreciate
2
StradaRedlands4946.00 lowrydr3101684.50 |
03-24-2024, 03:05 PM | #7 |
Colonel
379
Rep 2,365
Posts
Drives: 2007 E90 323i (Cdn)
Join Date: May 2013
Location: Toronto, Canada
|
I’d do it, and the diff fluid at the same time too.
__________________
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-24-2024, 09:11 PM | #8 |
Private First Class
127
Rep 104
Posts |
I think what you are referring to is a flush rather than fluid and filter change. I've long heard not to do a flush (machine powered) on a high mileage tranny that hasn't had regular servicing. A simple fluid/filter change should be okay.
|
Appreciate
1
StradaRedlands4946.00 |
03-24-2024, 09:44 PM | #9 |
Brigadier General
596
Rep 3,386
Posts |
The claim is that over time shavings from the clutches flow around in the fluid creating friction on the clutches, so when you drain that fluid and filter you lose all that friction which in turn causes slippage.
IF that is true it means your transmission is already on its way out anyway so changing the fluid would only be speeding up the inevitable. IF it’s not true then you’re breathing new life into your transmission. So in either scenario you might as well just change it.
__________________
|
Appreciate
3
|
03-24-2024, 10:15 PM | #10 |
DIYer
266
Rep 306
Posts |
Yeap, if your transmission is still working relatively well like you describe then a fluid and filter change will likely just help. As other members have pointed out, you'll need multiple drain and fills to get all the old fluid out.
I really need to do a couple drain and fills on my ride. Just curious now with simple drain and fill. Do we just drain then fill until it spills out? I dropped my pan almost a year ago and had to run it through gears to get the right amount of fluid in the system. |
Appreciate
1
StradaRedlands4946.00 |
03-25-2024, 07:08 AM | #11 |
First Lieutenant
171
Rep 339
Posts |
Myth. If you want to do it correctly then buy mechtronics seal kit, fluid and filter. Depending on how the fluid looks, I would also consider doing a drain and fill again after driving a few hundred miles. Also you didnt say if it is a ZF or GM trans, but the GM (some years?) need that shift linkage replaced too.
|
Appreciate
3
|
03-25-2024, 10:04 AM | #12 |
Brigadier General
4946
Rep 3,006
Posts
Drives: 2006 BMW 330i MT
Join Date: Dec 2021
Location: SoCal
iTrader: (2)
Garage List 2006 BMW 330i [8.21]
2009 BMW 328i Touri ... [7.90] 2013 BMW X5 35i [7.63] 2011 BMW 528i [8.75] 2006 Mazda3 [5.50] |
I imagine you still need to go through the entire process of getting it to temp and going through all the gears, even with a drain/fill.
|
Appreciate
4
|
03-25-2024, 06:48 PM | #14 |
Lieutenant
178
Rep 582
Posts |
True story I took my car to the dealership and they refused to just drain and refill and replace filter (filter is part of the cover) at 125k miles. They said after something like 90k they won't replace the fluid. I think they are ignorant.... but alas with 225k miles I haven't done anything and I'm sure my fluid is well past it's prime.
|
Appreciate
2
StradaRedlands4946.00 lowrydr3101684.50 |
03-25-2024, 09:50 PM | #15 |
Second Lieutenant
123
Rep 259
Posts
Drives: 2007 335i Jb4 & perf. mods.
Join Date: Aug 2018
Location: Cloverdale, BC, Canada.
|
'The claim is that over time shavings from the clutches flow around in the fluid creating friction on the clutches, so when you drain that fluid and filter you lose all that friction which in turn causes slippage.'
This claim is well supported and represents a significant risk in respect to a higher mileage non serviced auto trans. How certain are you that yours hasn't been serviced? |
Appreciate
0
|
03-26-2024, 08:45 AM | #16 |
Great Teacher
1088
Rep 1,305
Posts
Drives: 06 e91 325ix
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: El Paso
|
The shifter mechanism has nothing to do with the trans itself.
And having lost a trans due to doing a fluid change I would be hesitant to recommend you change it, except to change it to a manual, lol.
__________________
‘06 e91 manual 325ix BarriqueRot
over Terra (one of 1), Nav, Sport, L7 A few OEM+ mods: MTech front bumper, MSport wheel & handbrake, 4AD trim, full rear shades, more to come… |
Appreciate
1
StradaRedlands4946.00 |
03-27-2024, 08:54 AM | #17 |
First Lieutenant
171
Rep 339
Posts |
You didn't "lose a transmission" from a fluid change. You lost it because of a LACK of maintenance and fluid changes. So many people ignore the fluids in the cooling system, brake system, transmission, transfer case, front and rear differentials, and blinkers. Its complete nonsense that BMW goes against what GM France and ZF clearly state as the recommended service intervals. BMW for all the shit they rip people off for at the dealerships could be making so much revenue on doing driveline services. The want you to change the brake fluid every 12 months (and thats just under compression in sealed lines) while telling customers that the fluid in a transmission, that is under extreme stress, heat and friction, that it is "lifetime".
|
Appreciate
3
|
03-27-2024, 10:29 AM | #18 | |
Lieutenant
367
Rep 462
Posts
Drives: Break My Wallet
Join Date: Feb 2023
Location: Ontario
|
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
1
StradaRedlands4946.00 |
03-27-2024, 12:06 PM | #19 | |
Robot
1685
Rep 2,191
Posts |
Quote:
I bought a 220K mile 325i with the ZF 6HP transmission and it wasn't shifting smoothly. Occasionally the transmission would make a screeching sound at high RPM shifts. I took it to a local independent BMW shop and they advised against a drain and fill, so I did it myself. It SIGNIFICANTLY improved the shifting and overall feel of the transmission, and eliminated that screeching sound. |
|
Appreciate
1
StradaRedlands4946.00 |
03-27-2024, 12:09 PM | #20 | |
Robot
1685
Rep 2,191
Posts |
Quote:
Just curious because for the ZF 6HP, the car has to be running in order to fill it to the correct level. I can easily see a scenario where someone services this transmission and fills it while the car isn't running, in which case it wouldn't have the proper amount of fluid, which could easily lead to damage. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-27-2024, 02:12 PM | #21 |
Second Lieutenant
297
Rep 246
Posts
Drives: Green '07 & Arctic '08 335i's
Join Date: Jan 2023
Location: Monterey Peninsula
|
Or, perhaps more catastrophic, the car is running, but the fluid level exceeds 50C and expands, leaving too little fluid for normal operation. Either way, yes you could ruin a perfectly good transmission by missteps in this fill/drain process.
|
Appreciate
0
|
03-27-2024, 11:35 PM | #22 |
Great Teacher
1088
Rep 1,305
Posts
Drives: 06 e91 325ix
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: El Paso
|
4l30e with real ATF3.
And yes I know all about the running whilst filling and cycling thru the gears to make sure the tc and passages are all filled amd being up to temp etc. It was done right. Still killed it. Op has no problem with the trans, but with feeling the shifter is stiffer when moving form park to drive. That’s no tramdps issue, that’s a shifter mech issue
__________________
‘06 e91 manual 325ix BarriqueRot
over Terra (one of 1), Nav, Sport, L7 A few OEM+ mods: MTech front bumper, MSport wheel & handbrake, 4AD trim, full rear shades, more to come… |
Appreciate
1
StradaRedlands4946.00 |
Bookmarks |
|
|